6 Atypical Ways to Get & Keep New Hires

There's always one. That person in your team who makes it difficult for everyone else. They are the ones that turn up late, have a bad attitude, are negative towards the rest of the team, and consistently look like they'd rather be at home in bed than at work.

Image source

You've tried everything. Weekly check-in meetings, the option to work from home once a week, and countless 'thank you, you did a great job' emails. Nothing works. Joe has been with the company for six months and, despite his glowing CV and track record in the field, you think you made a bad choice bringing him into the team.

So what went wrong? 

Unfortunately, when you get a new person into a role you barely know them from Adam. Going through the 'interview process', it's easy to forget that we are dealing with real people. Even the labels we use in recruitment evoke distance and detachment between the company hiring and the individual being hired.

How can we know who we're really hiring? 

Unfortunately, people often come to a new role to escape something; they: 

• were a bad fit for a team
• didn't feel challenged
• didn't get along with their boss
• had outgrown the role
• wanted a higher salary for their efforts
• or, they were in a bad place in life, and they thought a new job would be the answer.

With all of this going on, it becomes rare that a new role will meet all of the person's expectations. 

So what's the answer?

The hiring processes used in today's workplaces are designed to help us know as much as we can in a short period and a cost effective manner. This means making drastic changes to hiring to allow us to spend quality time with future employees before they join the organisations is, in most cases, not possible. 

"We can't ever truly know who we're hiring, but we can get a positive and honest culture in place right from the outset."

Here are six great ways to get and keep the right new hires:

1. Ask them to be completely honest with you in an interview. 

Sometimes people arrive at your organisation just because they need a job. When this is the case, they are keen to say anything, or claim they will do anything in a role, even if its not their strength. Be sure to ask people what they love most at work. You'll see their face light up when they are being really honest, and it will help you to know if they are really right for the role. 

2. Try the informal approach:

Take your new starter out of the office for a coffee. Being in an informal setting can help people to be more open and honest with you about how they are settling in, and they will be more likely to share what's working and what's not. 

Image source

3. Ask the questions you don't want to know the answers to:

Try not to ignore the situation when people are difficult, there's always a reason people are challenging. Work with them as much as you can and be sure to ask the tough questions; "you seem down, is there something going on at work or home that we can help with?"

4. Give people options:

Help them to feel that if this wasn't the right move for them, or you, that you will give them support to find what is. Perhaps help them to move to another part of the company if that's and option. 

5. Make sure they know the cooling off period is for them as well as you: 

Encourage people to consider that the first few months they are in a role is as much a time for reflection about whether it's what they want, as it is for you to decide if they are a good fit for the role. Giving people a sense of control - and allowing them to continue to go to interviews if either of you is unsure - is a good way to help people feel engaged and not trapped. 

6. Give people the opportunity to make a difference: Your new hire has fresh eyes into the business, and the freshness isn't there forever so use it wisely. Ask people to tell you what works well here and what doesn't, and listen to them! Listening to and acting on the views of your people is a great way to engage them.